Is Recycling Really Worth The Effort?

We all try to do it, and it’s easier than ever. But is recycling really worth the effort?

By Alice Hailey

In the Western world, people have generally got the message about recycling. Over the last 10-20 years, we’ve stopped throwing everything into landfill and have begun to take more responsibility for tossing recyclable materials into separate bins. In fact, in some parts of the world, people now have nearly half a dozen different bins for recycling! 

But…is recycling really worth the effort?

The sad reality is that over half of the items we put into the recycling bin aren’t even recycled at all. 

In the USA, only around 9% of all plastic is recycled. And what is given a second life is likely to have a huge CO2 footprint. How so? Well, it’s probably shipped to a developing country for sorting and processing.

In fact, we pass off such a huge quantity of trash labelled as ‘recyclable’ to other countries that they are starting to refuse it. China and the Philippines are the two most current examples.

Businesses in particular are reluctant to recycle. That’s because unlike households, they’re often charged for baling cardboard and other waste. And whilst costs are high now, these are expected to increase in the future. That’s discouraging, because businesses generally create more rubbish than the average household. Oh, and be careful you throw out the right kind of plastic into your bin. Even a small amount of the wrong type can cause an entire batch of recycled plastic to become contaminated

So, does that mean we – households and businesses alike – should stop recycling altogether? Or is there a better way?

How does recycling work?

If you think your bottles, packaging and tins just go into some magic recycling machine that makes them into other materials, well, you’re wrong.

Here’s what generally happens when you recycle say, a plastic bottle:

1. Materials are collected from household bins. These are usually mixed plastic, paper, and aluminium that need to be separated by companies (and it’s not cheap to do so!). Around half of all materials received by the recycling company are not actually recyclable due to being the wrong type of material or too dirty, and will be incinerated or thrown into landfill.

2. When the plastics have been separated from metals and papers, they’re then sorted into type of plastic and sometimes, colour.

3. The plastics are run through a shredding machine. Afterwards, the shreds are washed, dried and melted.

4. The melted plastic is transformed by a large machine into flakes, which can then be spun into a very fine ‘thread’ like cotton candy.

5. These threads are used by industry to make a wide variety of products, from clothing and carpets to packaging and new bottles.

The saddest part of this is that even when used materials are perfectly and easily recycled, they tend to be made into ‘lesser’ products.

A plastic bottle, for example, may be processed into unrecyclable packaging materials that end up in landfill.

So, recycling often only delays the inevitable pollution by say, one disposable product’s lifetime.

Is Recycling Really Worth The Effort?

Greenwashing is rampant

The problem with today’s current recycling programs is that they just don’t work.

As mentioned above, half of all rubbish tossed into ‘recycling’ bins isn’t actually recycled. But it does give the consumer the sense of satisfaction that it’s ‘ok’ to buy stuff in plastic packaging because it can be recycled. Though often, this is not the case.

The best example? Coffee shops like Starbucks, Tim Hortons, Dunkin’ Donuts, etc. They all have recycling bins in store for their coffee cups. They ask customers to throw out organic waste in one bin, coffee cups and plastics in another, and paper in another.

But guess what? Apart from Tetrapaks, one of the most un-recyclable items we use every day are takeaway cups. Why? Because they’re lined with a fine film of plastic that’s impossible to separate from the paper cup- and which doesn’t biodegrade.

And if that’s not bad enough, get this: a whopping 6.5 million trees are cut down each year, just to make takeaway cups!

Think of how many entire forests that is! If you love coffee and tea on the go, please always bring your own refillable cup (and that goes for water, too – take your own thermos with you!)

After all, is recycling really worth the effort when you can eliminate the need for disposable products in the first place?


Plastic is the problem

A better solution is obviously to cut out plastic altogether from the product’s lifecycle. Plastic only became popular in consumer markets around one generation ago, and we did just fine without it before.

But since younger generations are more accustomed to using this material, we should be using only biodegradable plastics made from plant based materials. These do exist, and they are fairly cheap to make. The problem is that the plastics industry is tightly connected to the petroleum industry, which is still very powerful.

I think the responsibility for recycling plastic could be placed where it properly belongs: in the hands of the manufacturers. If they are forced to pay for the disposal of their own products, you can bet that they’ll quickly switch to the cheapest option, which is often to reuse.

For example, glass bottles were once the only option for purchasing soft drinks. And because the manufacturer could re-use them, deposits were left. So, if you bought a Coke for £1, you’d also have to pay a 10 cent deposit fee. This would be refunded when you returned the bottle to the shop. The bottle would then be collected by Coke to refill.

This is called a closed loop recycling system, and it’s older than you think. The same system was used by milk delivery trucks to refill milk bottles when the stuff was sold in glass. It’s only recently that drinks have been packaged in Tetrapaks (which are 100% non-recyclable) and plastic bottles. A closed-loop recycling process, on the other hand, ensures we get the maximum amount of use out of any material, reducing the amount that ends up in landfill. 

Is Recycling Really Worth The Effort?

Tech – and creativity – can help

Within 20 years, I predict that there will be a closed-loop recyclability index (CLR) displayed on every product. This will indicate both the sustainability of the manufacturing process and the cash value of the packaging once recycled using a system like ReCircle. As with ingredient labelling on food, the CLR will influence what we as consumers decide to buy. 

As with plastic alternatives, technological innovations can further help to reduce waste.

For example, the ReCircle appliance uses sensors to identify and segment different types of plastic, glass and metal. The appliance then washes and grinds the recyclable materials for storage in its base. These pure materials are then picked up by recycling companies. And the best part? The recycler is reimbursed for the weight of recycled materials. 

Tech like this encourages all of us to recycle by offering monetary incentives. And since they only provide pure, recyclable base materials, they are a key step towards achieving 100% closed-loop recycling and helping to empower households to make purchasing decisions which take into account a product’s lifecycle assessment. After all, if you could buy product A which isn’t recyclable, or recyclable product B for the same price…? Well, the choice is a no-brainer.

Creative entrepreneurs have come up with other technological ideas that can reduce waste. Loop, for example, gives new life to everyday items from foods to plastic combs by transforming them into reusable packaging. When you’re finished with the product, you can return the packaging, so it can be cleaned, refilled and reused, thus creating a revolutionary, closed-loop system.

So, is recycling really worth it?

So, is recycling really worth the effort? The answer is yes – kind of.

Metals and paper are much more easily recycled than plastic. And for that reason, I believe plastic should be completely phased out of most consumer products. After all, it’s plastic, not paper or tins, that has cause an island of waste three times the size of France floating in our oceans! 

The worst part of plastic recycling schemes in general is that the public doesn’t think twice about consuming stuff packaged in plastic. The attitude is ‘oh well, I can just recycle it.” But as I explained above, plastic is a problem. Period.

Fortunately, people are becoming more aware of the problems with plastic recycling, and are demanding change from their governments. For example, in January 2019, UK Prime Minister Theresa May pledged to eliminate the UK’s plastic waste by 2042. And many countries, including Mexico, England, Burma, India and Rwanda have banned free plastic bags in stores.

But how do we ensure such promises aren’t yet another greenwash? After all, the UK already said they were banning free plastic bags, but those are still readily available in any supermarket. The 3 cent charge doesn’t really deter anyone from using them.

Still, my vision of the future is a positive one. More innovative technological solutions and plastic alternatives are being created all the time. Plus, it seems Generation Z is particularly enthusiastic about ending plastic altogether. And why shouldn’t they be?

After all, it’s nothing short of their very future we’re talking about.

What do you think? Is recycling really worth the effort? Let us know in the comments below?


Chere Di Boscio
Latest posts by Chere Di Boscio (see all)

2 thoughts on “Is Recycling Really Worth The Effort?”

  1. I agree that plastic should be phased out altogether. I think that the shift from glass to plastic bottles coincided with the decline of small shops in favour of supermarkets and then with the expansion and relocation of supermarkets to out-of-town locations. I can remember that a bottle of Corona fizzy pop (which I wouldn’t even contemplate drinking nowadays) had a 2p deposit, which in the 1970’s for a kid was worth returning the bottle for.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top